SETDB1 (Q15047, KMT1E/ESET) - the second H3K9me3 writer: it represses the fusion's own targets via the PAF1 complex, it is required in fetal liver HSPCs and in leukaemic stem cells, and it is a broad dependency in half the CRISPR panel - three published directions that do not agree
also called SETDB1 · ESET · KMT1E · KIAA0067 · KG1T · TDRD21 · Q15047 · SETB1_HUMAN · Histone-lysine N-methyltransferase SETDB1 · ERG-associated protein with SET domain · Histone H3-K9 methyltransferase 4 · SET domain bifurcated 1
SETDB1 is the second enzyme that writes H3K9me3, the silencing tag. In leukaemia it points three ways at once: raising it switches off the genes the KMT2A fusion needs, but deleting it also kills leukaemic stem cells and the normal fetal blood stem cells they come from, and half of all cancer cell lines need it to grow.
The same thing, for a scientist
**The reason this entry matters is not that SETDB1 is a target - it is that its three published directions contradict each other, and only one of them was in this corpus.** **Identity.** Q15047, `SETB1_HUMAN`, **1,291 aa**, primary SETDB1, synonyms **ESET, KMT1E, KIAA0067**, HGNC:10761, 1q21.3. Three Tudor domains (the first degenerate), an MBD at 594-665, pre-SET 727-800, a **bifurcated SET 803-1266** and post-SET 1275-1291; 25 PDB entries [E1]. **Direction 1 - a brake on the fusion programme.** Genes directly bound by MLL-AF9 are significantly down-regulated on SETDB1 over-expression in mouse MLL-AF9 cells; 193 of them have reduced promoter H3K9 methylation in AML patient samples relative to normal human CD34+ cells; an overlapping set is up-regulated by SETDB1 knockdown in human THP-1 cells; and higher SETDB1 tracks with lower *HOXA9* and *MEIS1* in human AML [E2]. The recruiter is the PAF1 complex: PAF1c physically interacts with SETDB1 in MLL-AF9 cells, the interaction is stabilised by a CDC73_3YF mutant that cannot support AML growth, and stabilising it raises promoter H3K9me3 at *Meis1* and *Hoxa9* while reducing their transcription [E3]. This is the limb `mark-h3k9me3` rests on, and PAF1c is already in this graph as required for fusion localisation. **Direction 2 - required by the same cells it is supposed to restrain.** Setdb1 is the first H3K9 methyltransferase shown to be essential for maintenance of murine HSPCs; its deletion caused **rapid depletion of HSPCs and of leukaemic stem cells**, by ectopic activation of non-haematopoietic genes - the gluconeogenic enzymes *Fbp1* and *Fbp2* - which antagonised glycolysis and impaired ATP production [E4]. And in **mouse fetal liver HSPCs**, the cell compartment this graph holds as the index disease's origin, Setdb1 deletion compromises stem-cell function, enhances myeloerythroid differentiation and **impairs lymphoid development**, by loss of H3K9me3 at cryptic enhancers that PU.1 already binds despite the H3K9me3 [E5]. **Direction 3 - a broad dependency, not a selective one.** Mean gene effect **-0.529** across **1,258** screens with **50.4%** of lines below -0.5; in the 147 haematopoietic and lymphoid screens the mean is **-0.649** with 63.3% below -0.5 - deeper in blood than MEN1's -0.583 in the same call [E6]. **That is a dependency figure and this entry refuses to let it become a target nomination**, because a gene needed by half of all cancer lines and by normal fetal HSPCs has no therapeutic window on this evidence. **Its abundance is degradation-controlled too**, like SUV39H1's: TRIM28/KAP1 protects SETDB1 from degradation at telomeres, and knocking down TRIM28 raises ALT phenotypes [E7]. **Its reader recruits it**: the CHAMP1-POGZ-**HP1α** complex binds and recruits SETDB1 to heterochromatin and is required for double-strand-break repair there [E8]. **CTCF recruits it to breaks** alongside SUV39H1 [E9]. And in a leukaemia line it sits with TRIM28, ZNF274 and ATRX on the 3' exons of zinc-finger genes, which is the one place in the genome its occupancy is uncontroversial [E10]. **At the *KMT2A* locus: never measured, by anyone, in any cell.** `SETDB1[tiab] AND 11q23[tiab]` returns 0 and `SETDB1[tiab] AND KMT2A[tiab]` returns 2, neither on topic. Unlike SUV39H1 this one was answerable from deposited data, and this beat answered it: across **three K562 SETDB1 peak sets from two labs there is not one called peak anywhere in the 90 kb gene, in the breakpoint cluster region, at the exon-11 element, or within 50 kb of the gene** - with the ZNF274 gene-body positive control passing in two of the three. See `ana-q110-h3k9-writer-and-reader-occupancy-at-the-kmt2a-locus`.
This is real experimental data — atoms placed by crystallography or cryo-EM, deposited by the people who did the experiment.
I have never read one of these pictures before
A protein is one long chain of amino acids that folds up. The ribbon traces that chain from one end to the other; it is not a wire, it is a simplification of where the backbone runs. Drag to rotate, scroll to zoom.
Domains are the stretches of chain that do a particular job, and they are what the coloured blocks above the picture mark out. Click one and the view flies to it. In this project the important question about any domain is usually whether the fusion still has it — the labels say lost where it does not.
Anything in yellow sticks is a bound small molecule, which is usually the drug.
What this entry changes in the graph, stated plainly
mark-h3k9me3 argues that H3K9 methylation restrains the fusion programme, and its two strongest citations are the SETDB1 papers. That argument is sound as far as it goes and this entry does not withdraw it. What this entry adds is that the same gene, in the same lineage, has two other published directions that were not in this corpus at all:
- Setdb1 deletion depletes leukaemic stem cells as fast as it depletes normal HSPCs 4;
- Setdb1 is required in fetal liver HSPCs specifically for lymphoid development 5, which is the compartment and the lineage this disease arises in;
- and half of all CRISPR-screened lines depend on it 6.
So "lowering H3K9 methylation is the dangerous direction" is not the whole of what the SETDB1 literature says. It says that lowering SETDB1 kills the leukaemic stem cell and the normal fetal progenitor and most other cells, while lowering it genetically also de-represses the fusion's targets. Those are not contradictory results, they are results about different endpoints - but a graph that holds only one of them will sign an intervention wrongly.
No recommendation follows. The honest state is: this graph cannot sign a SETDB1 intervention, and the reason is now recorded rather than absent.
SETDB1 versus SUV39H1: what actually separates them
Both write H3K9me3, both are recruited to breaks by CTCF, and both are degradation-controlled. They separate on three things that matter here:
| SETDB1 | SUV39H1 | |
|---|---|---|
| compartment | non-pericentromeric; excluded from nucleoli; ZNF 3' exons; telomeres | pericentromeric, nucleus lamina, and nucleolar/rDNA in a leukaemia cell |
| reader that brings it | CHAMP1-POGZ-HP1alpha 8; TRIM28/KAP1 | HP1 (paralogue unspecified) and TRIM28/KAP1; and its own chromodomain reading H3K9me3 + H3K14ub |
| dependency | broad: 50.4% of lines below -0.5 | flat: 0.72% |
| ENCODE ChIP-seq | 3 experiments in K562 | none, any cell type |
| degradation control | TRIM28 protects it 7 | CUL5-ASB7 degrades it; lamin A protects it |
The compartment difference is the discriminating one for this graph's question, because the KMT2A exon-11 element is a transcribed, CTCF/cohesin-bound loop anchor - euchromatic, not pericentromeric and not nucleolar. On compartment alone SETDB1 is the better prior, and it is also the one the archive can answer for.
| uniprot | Q15047 |
|---|---|
| uniprot entry name | SETB1_HUMAN |
| gene symbol | SETDB1 |
| gene primary readback | SETDB1 |
| protein name | Histone-lysine N-methyltransferase SETDB1 |
| length AA | 1291 |
| hgnc ID | HGNC:10761 |
| ensembl gene ID | ENSG00000143379 |
| cytoband | 1q21.3 |
| how the accession was resolved | gene_exact:SETDB1 AND organism_id:9606 AND reviewed:true returned EXACTLY ONE reviewed record, gene_primary read back as SETDB1. Ensembl id from the HGNC primary ensembl_gene_id. |
| PDB note | UniProt cross-references 25 PDB entries; the 19 listed here are those identifiers as returned by the Q15047 record on 2026-09-22, with the five 5QT*/6BH* fragment-screen siblings and one further entry omitted from the list rather than paraphrased. NO polymer entity was fetched for any of them, so nothing is claimed about which construct, which domain or what resolution - an entry count tracks how easy a protein was to crystallise and is not a druggability statement. |
| localization | UniProt Q15047: Nucleus [ECO:0000269, PubMed:27732843]; Cytoplasm [ECO:0000269, PubMed:26405197, 27732843]; Chromosome [ECO:0000269, PubMed:27029610, 29234025]. The cytoplasmic pool is coded and is not a curation artefact, which matters because a writer with a cytoplasmic fraction can be regulated by import rather than by activity. |
| subnuclear localization | Associated with NON-pericentromeric regions of chromatin [ECO:0000269, PubMed:27029610]; recruited to H3K9me and H3K19ac marks [ECO:0000269, PubMed:29234025]; and **excluded from nucleoli and from islands of condensed chromatin** [ECO:0000269, PubMed:27732843]. That triad separates it cleanly from SUV39H1, which is pericentromeric, laminar, and nucleolar in a leukaemia cell via PHF6. Its one uncontroversial genomic address is the **3' exons of zinc-finger genes**, co-occupied with TRIM28, ZNF274 and ATRX [E10]. Also localised to **telomeres** in ALT cells, where TRIM28 protects it from degradation [E7], and to **heterochromatin at centromeres and telomeres** when brought by the CHAMP1-POGZ-HP1alpha complex [E8]. NONE of this is a measurement at the KMT2A locus and none is in a KMT2A-rearranged cell. |
| localization shown for fusion | false |
| cell type | The fusion evidence is mouse MLL-AF9 cells plus human THP-1 (KMT2A::MLLT3, myeloid) and human AML patient samples versus normal human CD34+ cells [E2, E3]. The essential-function evidence is murine HSPCs [E4] and **murine fetal liver HSPCs** [E5] - the latter being this graph's `cell-type-fetal-liver-hsc`. The CTCF-DSB cascade is U2OS and HEK-293T [E9]. The ZNF 3'-exon occupancy is multiple human lines including K562 [E10]. NO KMT2A::AFF1 cell, no B-lineage leukaemia cell, no infant material anywhere in this entry. |
| cell state | QUIESCENCE and DIFFERENTIATION are the state variables. Setdb1-deficient fetal liver HSPCs show reduced quiescence and increased proliferation with a lineage-biased transcriptional programme, enhanced myeloerythroid and impaired LYMPHOID development [E5]; in adult HSPCs deletion causes rapid depletion with a metabolic mechanism - ectopic gluconeogenic enzymes antagonising glycolysis - so the state change is bioenergetic as well as transcriptional [E4]. DNA DAMAGE is the third state: SETDB1 is recruited to breaks by CTCF [E9] and to heterochromatic breaks by the CHAMP1 complex [E8]. |
| epigenetic readout | WRITER of H3K9me3 (H3K9me3-specific, per PMID 39689172's own description), and simultaneously a READER through three Tudor domains and an MBD; UniProt records recruitment to H3K9me and H3K19ac. Like SUV39H1 it is also a degradation SUBSTRATE, protected by TRIM28 [E7]. |
| mark written | H3K9me3 |
| writer of that mark | mark-h3k9me3 |
| shown for fusion | MLL-AF9 in mouse and THP-1 (KMT2A::MLLT3) in human, as a REPRESSOR of the fusion's own targets - genes directly bound by MLL-AF9 fall on SETDB1 over-expression, and promoter H3K9me3 at Meis1 and Hoxa9 rises when the PAF1c-SETDB1 interaction is stabilised (PMIDs 33054052, 29774127). Nothing in KMT2A::AFF1, nothing in B-lineage, nothing in infant material, and no measurement of SETDB1 on any fusion protein or at the KMT2A locus. |
| absence class | measured-not-analysed |
alias traps measured here
{
"ESET": "UNUSABLE as a bare PubMed operand. ESET[tiab] AND MLL[tiab] returns 0 with a non-empty querytranslation, and the token is a four-letter acronym that this graph's own registry grep matches inside the word 'typeset' in an unrelated row - so a case-insensitive substring check on it produces a false registry hit. Searched and recorded, not assumed.",
"KMT1E": "KMT1E[tiab] AND MLL[tiab] returns 0. So on this gene the alias widening resolved to no, in both directions, and the approved symbol is the productive operand - the OPPOSITE of the EHMT2/G9a row already in the registry, where the retired alias is the better operand. The alias question had no default direction here either.",
"registry_status": "no row for SETDB1, ESET or KMT1E in data/symbol-collisions.json as of 2026-09-22, checked with the corrected rule-88 command over d['collisions'] (175 rows)."
}domains — the numbers behind the chart
[
{
"name": "Tudor 1; degenerate",
"start": 201,
"end": 251
},
{
"name": "Tudor 2",
"start": 257,
"end": 320
},
{
"name": "Tudor 3",
"start": 347,
"end": 403
},
{
"name": "MBD (methyl-CpG-binding domain)",
"start": 594,
"end": 665
},
{
"name": "Pre-SET",
"start": 727,
"end": 800
},
{
"name": "SET; bifurcated",
"start": 803,
"end": 1266
},
{
"name": "Post-SET",
"start": 1275,
"end": 1291
}
]PDB IDS
[ "3DLM", "4X3S", "5KCH", "5KCO", "5KE2", "5KE3", "5KH6", "6AU2", "6AU3", "6BHD", "6BHE", "7C9N", "7CAJ", "7CD9", "7CJT", "8G5E", "8IYA", "8UWP", "9CUW" ]
the three directions do not agree
{
"direction_1": "SETDB1 represses MLL-fusion targets; raising it suppresses transformation (PMIDs 33054052, 29774127). Implication: a SETDB1 inhibitor could worsen KMT2A-rearranged disease.",
"direction_2": "Setdb1 deletion rapidly depletes HSPCs AND LEUKAEMIC STEM CELLS (PMID 27301860), and compromises fetal liver HSPCs with impaired lymphoid development (PMID 39689172). Implication: a SETDB1 inhibitor would kill leukaemic stem cells - and normal fetal and adult HSPCs with them.",
"direction_3": "SETDB1 is a broad CRISPR dependency, 50.4% of 1,258 lines below -0.5 and 63.3% of blood lines. Implication: the loss-of-viability phenotype is not fusion-selective and is not a window.",
"how_this_graph_had_it": "mark-h3k9me3 and drug-unc0642 cite PMID 33054052 for direction 1 and neither entry records directions 2 or 3. So the graph's H3K9 safety argument was resting on the one of the three that supports it, and the other two were not in the corpus at all.",
"are_they_reconcilable": "Possibly, and the reconciliation is a timescale: direction 1 is target-gene transcription in days, direction 2 is stem-cell maintenance over a transplant, direction 3 is proliferation over a 21-day screen. But no experiment measures two of them in one system, so the reconciliation is a hypothesis and not a finding."
}the beat question answered
{
"question": "Has SETDB1 ever been localised at the KMT2A locus, in any cell type?",
"answer": "NO in the literature - and unlike SUV39H1, the archive CAN answer, and this beat asked it.",
"literature_bound_2026_09_22": {
"SETDB1[tiab] AND 11q23[tiab]": 0,
"SETDB1[tiab] AND KMT2A[tiab]": 2,
"what_those_two_are": "PMID 30458291 (mangrove rivulus fish Kdm/Kmt gene families) and PMID 25467983 (conserved higher-order chromatin at the NMDA receptor gene) - neither about the KMT2A locus",
"SETDB1[tiab] AND MLL[tiab]": 4,
"what_those_four_are": "33054052 and 29774127 (the fusion-target papers cited here), 21480048 (arecoline cytotoxicity in K562), 10343109 (the 1999 paper assigning SETDB1 to 1q21 by in situ hybridisation - 'MLL' there is not the leukaemia gene in context)",
"SETDB1[tiab] AND breakpoint[tiab]": 1,
"what_that_one_is": "PMID 42055326, HIRA-SETDB1-H3K9me3 in K562 - and 'Breakpoint Cluster Region' there is the BCR GENE of BCR::ABL1, not the KMT2A breakpoint cluster region this graph abbreviates as the BCR. This collision is reported for the registry.",
"alias_widening": "ESET[tiab] AND MLL[tiab] = 0; KMT1E[tiab] AND MLL[tiab] = 0. Both run, both recorded, neither productive.",
"bound_class": "titles and abstracts only (rule 80); a SETDB1 track over KMT2A in a supporting figure is invisible to all of the above."
},
"archive_route_taken": "ENCODE holds 3 released SETDB1 ChIP-seq experiments in K562 (ENCSR000EWD, ENCSR000EWI, ENCSR000AUT; two labs). All three were read at the KMT2A BCR, the exon-11 CTCF element and the whole gene, at both peak and signal level, in ana-q110-h3k9-writer-and-reader-occupancy-at-the-kmt2a-locus. RESULT: zero called peaks in the gene or within 50 kb in all three, genome-wide peak counts 1,615 / 3,753 / 1,660, and the ZNF274 gene-body positive control passing in ENCSR000EWD and ENCSR000EWI but not in the single-replicate ENCSR000AUT, whose zero therefore carries no weight. K562 is not KMT2A-rearranged and not a CD34+ progenitor, which is the substitution's cost.",
"absence_class": "measured-not-analysed"
}depmap
{
"n_screens_with_gene_effect": 1258,
"mean_gene_effect": -0.5288,
"median_gene_effect": -0.5025,
"min_gene_effect": -2.5919,
"frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.504,
"frac_below_minus_1_0": 0.0612,
"n_blood_screens": 147,
"blood_tissue_blocks": [
"hematopoietic tissue",
"lymphoid tissue"
],
"blood_mean_gene_effect": -0.6491,
"blood_frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.6327,
"n_tissue_blocks_flattened": 29,
"open_targets_data_version": {
"year": "26",
"month": "06",
"iteration": null
},
"depmap_release": null,
"in_the_same_call_for_scale": {
"MEN1": {
"mean": -0.3616,
"frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.2893,
"blood_mean": -0.5831
},
"SUV39H1": {
"mean": -0.0575,
"frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.0072,
"blood_mean": -0.1091
},
"CBX5": {
"mean": -0.083,
"frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.004,
"blood_mean": -0.0804
},
"CBX1": {
"mean": -0.3494,
"frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.1655,
"blood_mean": -0.3187
},
"EHMT2": {
"mean": -0.226,
"frac_below_minus_0_5": 0.0747,
"blood_mean": -0.2485
}
},
"rule_83": "no DepMap release identifier is present in the Open Targets payload; only the OT data version is recorded, and a fetch date is not a release.",
"rule_84": "no median-split proportion anywhere - these are absolute Chronos thresholds. And the comparison with MEN1 is NOT offered as a selectivity claim: a pan-panel mean is the wrong statistic for comparing a broad dependency with a selective one, which is exactly what this pair is, so the two are shown side by side and neither is ranked.",
"payload_guard": "panel maximum 1,258 screens across the eight genes in one call, clearing the ~1,000 guard; POLR2A run as a live zero-screen control in the same call returned 0 blocks and 0 screens with its approvedSymbol readback passing.",
"reading": "SETDB1 is a broad dependency. THIS IS NOT A TARGET FINDING. Half of all screened lines and nearly two thirds of blood lines need it, normal murine fetal and adult HSPCs need it, and nothing here is fusion-selective."
}chemical matter
{
"inhibitors": "SETDB1[tiab] AND inhibitor[tiab] returns 50 records on 2026-09-22; no SGC-class selective chemical probe was identified and SETDB1[tiab] AND \"chemical probe\"[tiab] returns 0.",
"degraders": "SETDB1[tiab] AND degrader[tiab] returns 2 records and BOTH fail a title check - PMID 39039255 is a Smurf1 paper and PMID 38749268 is a KDM5B PROTAC. So on this query there is no published SETDB1 degrader.",
"why_it_is_recorded": "so that nobody reads the dependency figure and the absence of a probe as an opportunity. The dependency is broad and the essential-function evidence is in fetal HSPCs; the missing probe is not the obstacle."
}- THE DEPENDENCY FIGURE IS NOT A TARGET NOMINATION AND THIS ENTRY SAYS SO IN ITS OWN DATA BLOCK. SETDB1 is below -0.5 in 50.4% of 1,258 CRISPR screens and in 63.3% of the 147 blood screens - deeper in blood than MEN1 in the same call. A gene needed by half of all screened cancer lines is a broad dependency, and floor compression at that depth also means a fusion-selectivity contrast on it would be close to uninterpretable.
- Essential-function toxicity is documented in exactly the wrong compartment. Setdb1 deletion rapidly depletes adult murine HSPCs (PMID 27301860) and compromises murine FETAL LIVER HSPCs with impaired lymphoid development (PMID 39689172). The patient is an infant whose lymphoid system is being built from that compartment, so a SETDB1 inhibitor is a marrow-and-lymphoid-toxicity proposal before it is anything else.
- The sign of a SETDB1 intervention in this disease is unknown and this graph previously held only the limb that supports one answer. Raising SETDB1 suppresses MLL-fusion targets (PMID 33054052); deleting it kills leukaemic stem cells (PMID 27301860). Either direction has a published rationale and neither has been tested against the other's endpoint in one system.
- There is no selective chemical matter, and that is not the obstacle. SETDB1[tiab] AND degrader[tiab] returns 2 records and both fail a title check (a Smurf1 paper and a KDM5B PROTAC); SETDB1[tiab] AND "chemical probe"[tiab] returns 0. Building a probe would not resolve any of the three contradictory directions above, because the contradiction is in the biology and not in the pharmacology.
- Perturbing the mark is not perturbing one element. SETDB1 loss in fetal HSPCs opens cryptic enhancers genome-wide that PU.1 already occupies (PMID 39689172), and SETDB1's own occupancy sits on transcribed, H3K36me3-high ZNF 3' exons whose H3K9me3 loss causes DNA damage (PMID 27029610). A strategy aimed at H3K9me3 at one CTCF anchor has two documented routes to genome-wide consequences.
- Which leukaemia model supplied the leukaemic stem cells that Setdb1 deletion depleted in PMID 27301860? The abstract does not say, and the answer decides whether directions 1 and 2 of this entry are a contradiction within KMT2A-fusion biology or two facts about different diseases. It is one paper read.
- Does SETDB1 occupy the KMT2A locus in a blood cell? ANSWERED for K562 this cycle - no called peak in the gene or within 50 kb, in three peak sets from two labs. What remains open is whether that is a resting-state property or an absence full stop, because both writers are recruited to breaks transiently and no archive holds a damage arm at this locus; and whether a KMT2A-rearranged line would read the same, which needs wet work.
- Is the lymphoid defect in Setdb1-deficient fetal liver HSPCs a B-lineage defect specifically, and at which stage? The compartment is this disease's putative origin and the abstract says only 'impaired lymphoid development'.
- Does SETDB1 sit on cryptic enhancers in a KMT2A::AFF1 B-lymphoblast as it does in murine fetal HSPCs? The finding that PU.1 binds H3K9me3-marked cryptic enhancers in wild-type fetal HSPCs (PMID 39689172) is a mechanism by which a mark change at any element could change transcription-factor access without changing transcription, and this graph has no such measurement.
- Is the PAF1c-SETDB1 interaction independently replicated? Both papers establishing it come from one group, and it is the hinge of mark-h3k9me3's argument that H3K9 methylation restrains the fusion programme.
- E1established confidence 5 of 5: Multiple independent lines of evidence; treated as settled in the field.database
SETDB1 is UniProt Q15047, entry name SETB1_HUMAN, 1,291 amino acids, primary gene name SETDB1 with synonyms ESET, KIAA0067 and KMT1E, HGNC:10761 at 1q21.3, Ensembl ENSG00000143379; its feature table annotates three Tudor domains at 201-251 (degenerate), 257-320 and 347-403, an MBD at 594-665, pre-SET at 727-800, a bifurcated SET at 803-1266 and post-SET at 1275-1291; its coded subcellular locations are Nucleus, Cytoplasm and Chromosome, with notes that it associates with non-pericentromeric chromatin, is recruited to H3K9me and H3K19ac marks, and is excluded from nucleoli and islands of condensed chromatin; and it cross-references 25 PDB entries.
UniProtKB Q15047 (SETB1_HUMAN) - Histone-lysine N-methyltransferase SETDB1, Homo sapiens; with HGNC:10761 · UniProt Consortium; HUGO Gene Nomenclature Committee · UniProt Knowledgebase / HGNC 2026What this evidence cannot show
Exactly one reviewed human record was returned by gene_exact and its gene_primary was read back. The 1,291 aa length is a genuine discriminator against every other H3K9 methyltransferase in this graph (SUV39H1 412, SUV39H2 410, EHMT2 1,210), so unlike the SUV39H1/H2 pair the length assertion here does real work. The subnuclear notes are UniProt's summaries of individual papers and each rests on a single PMID; none was independently read for this entry except PubMed:27029610, which is [E10].
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- Rule 91: the 'recruited to H3K9me and H3K19ac' note rests on one PMID and 'H3K19ac' is an unusual mark to see cited for a writer's recruitment - it is not a mark this graph holds an entry for and it was not verified here. Treat the recruitment half of the note as uncoded for present purposes.
- A 25-entry PDB footprint says this protein crystallises well, not that it is druggable. No entity, construct, span or resolution was checked, and the Tudor-domain fragment screens in that list are structures of one small domain rather than of the catalytic machine.
- E2strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
In MOUSE MLL-AF9 cells and human THP-1, SETDB1-mediated H3K9 methylation suppresses MLL-fusion target expression and leukaemic transformation: genes directly bound by MLL-AF9 are significantly down-regulated on SETDB1 over-expression; 193 of those genes have reduced promoter H3K9 methylation in AML patient samples relative to normal human CD34+ cells; an overlapping set is up-regulated by CRISPR-Cas9 SETDB1 knockdown in human THP-1 cells; and the G9a inhibitor UNC0638 reduces both H3K9me2 and H3K9me3 in mouse lineage-negative bone marrow.
SETDB1 mediated histone H3 lysine 9 methylation suppresses MLL-fusion target expression and leukemic transformation. · Ropa J, Saha N, Hu H, Peterson LF, et al. · Haematologica 2020What this evidence cannot show
Mouse MLL-AF9 and human THP-1 (KMT2A::MLLT3) - both MYELOID, neither the index fusion, no B-lineage and no infant material (rule 73). The gain-of-function arm is over-expression of a methyltransferase, which can act through non-histone substrates. Already cited four times in this graph (drug-unc0642, mark-h3k9me1, mark-h3k9me3, mechanism-h3k9me1-2-ctcf-balance-gates-kmt2a-rearrangement), so the conclusion is not new here - what is new is that it is now stated beside [E4] and [E6], which point the other way.
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- [E4] is the direct opposition and it is in the same lineage: Setdb1 deletion caused rapid depletion of leukaemic stem cells as well as HSPCs (PMID 27301860, Blood). A gene whose over-expression suppresses transformation and whose deletion kills the leukaemic stem cell cannot be carrying a single therapeutic sign, and neither paper measures the other's endpoint.
- The 193-gene patient comparison is AML samples against normal CD34+ cells, so it confounds fusion status with differentiation state - AML blasts and CD34+ progenitors differ in H3K9 methylation for many reasons, and the comparison does not isolate the fusion.
- E3strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
The PAF1 complex recruits SETDB1 to fusion targets. In MLL-AF9-transformed AML cells the PAF1 complex physically interacts with SETDB1 - an interaction stabilised by a CDC73_3YF mutant that cannot support AML cell growth - and over-expression of SETDB1 or stabilisation of the PAF1c-SETDB1 interaction increases promoter H3K9 trimethylation at Meis1 and Hoxa9 by ChIP while reducing their transcription; in human AML patients higher SETDB1 expression is associated with reduced HOXA9 and MEIS1.
PAF1 complex interactions with SETDB1 mediate promoter H3K9 methylation and transcriptional repression of Hoxa9 and Meis1 in acute myeloid leukemia. · Ropa J, Saha N, Chen Z, Serio J, et al. · Oncotarget 2018What this evidence cannot show
Mouse MLL-AF9 myeloid cells. Already cited three times here (gene-cdc73, gene-paf1, mark-h3k9me3) and included in this entry because SETDB1 had no entry of its own to carry it. The CDC73_3YF mutant is a phospho-tyrosine mutant, so the recruitment is conditional on a signalling state, and Oncotarget is a journal whose editorial standing in this period is contested - the result's replication is [E2] from the same group, which is not independent.
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- The same PAF1c subunit recruits the OTHER H3K9me3 writer in non-haematopoietic cells: parafibromin/CDC73 aa 128-227 recruits SUV39H1 to the cyclin D1 promoter (PMID 19906718), and SHP2 dephosphorylation of the same tyrosines flips parafibromin to beta-catenin-mediated activation (PMID 21726809). So CDC73's phospho-state selects between two writers and an activator, and which writer arrives in a KMT2A::AFF1 B-lymphoblast is not established by either literature.
- Both papers on this axis come from one group, so the PAF1c-SETDB1 interaction has no independent replication known to this project, and it is the mechanistic hinge of mark-h3k9me3's whole restraining argument.
- E4strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
Setdb1 is essential for murine haematopoietic stem and progenitor cells AND for leukaemic stem cells. Setdb1 is the first H3K9 methyltransferase shown to be essential for the maintenance of HSPCs in mice; its deletion caused the rapid depletion of HSPCs as well as of LEUKAEMIC STEM CELLS; in contrast to embryonic stem cells, endogenous retroviral elements were largely repressed in Setdb1-deficient HSPCs, and instead a list of non-haematopoietic genes was ectopically activated after reductions in H3K9me3, including the key gluconeogenic enzyme genes Fbp1 and Fbp2; the ectopic gluconeogenic enzymes antagonised glycolysis and impaired ATP production, compromising the repopulating capacity of HSPCs.
Setdb1 maintains hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells by restricting the ectopic activation of nonhematopoietic genes. · Koide S, Oshima M, Takubo K, Yamazaki S, et al. · Blood 2016What this evidence cannot show
Abstract level; murine, adult haematopoiesis, and the abstract does not state which leukaemia model the depleted leukaemic stem cells came from - so 'leukaemic stem cells' here cannot be attributed to a KMT2A fusion without reading the paper. That single uncertainty is load-bearing for this entry's central tension and is the first thing a follow-up should close.
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- Not knowing the leukaemia model is a real limit on how far this opposes [E2]. If the LSCs were from a non-KMT2A model, the contradiction is between 'SETDB1 restrains MLL-fusion targets' and 'SETDB1 is needed by some other leukaemia's stem cells', which is a weaker conflict. The entry states the tension at the strength the abstract supports and no further.
- The mechanism found is metabolic - gluconeogenic enzymes antagonising glycolysis - not transcriptional de-repression of a fusion programme. A metabolic route means the HSPC phenotype could be unrelated to the H3K9me3 function this graph cares about, and the mark change is the upstream event rather than the measured cause.
- E5strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
In MOUSE FETAL LIVER HSPCs - the compartment this graph holds as the index disease's origin - deletion of Setdb1 compromises stem-cell function, enhances myeloerythroid differentiation and IMPAIRS LYMPHOID DEVELOPMENT; Setdb1-deficient fetal HSPCs show reduced quiescence and increased proliferation with a lineage-biased transcriptional programme; and the mechanism is loss of H3K9me3 with increased chromatin accessibility at cryptic enhancers that haematopoietic transcription factors such as PU.1 already bind in wild-type HSPCs despite the H3K9me3 status, so SETDB1 restricts activation of non-physiological TF binding sites.
Histone methyltransferase SETDB1 safeguards mouse fetal hematopoiesis by suppressing activation of cryptic enhancers. · Kazerani M, Cernilogar F, Pasquarella A, Hinterberger M, et al. · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2024What this evidence cannot show
Abstract level; murine fetal liver, no human material, no fusion. 'Impaired lymphoid development' is the phenotype most relevant to this graph and it is one clause of an abstract - the magnitude, the stage at which lymphoid output fails, and whether B-lineage specifically is affected are not established here.
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- It points the opposite way to any therapeutic use of a SETDB1 inhibitor in an infant. The compartment in which SETDB1 is required for lymphoid development is the compartment the index fusion is thought to arise in, and the patient is a child whose normal fetal-derived haematopoiesis is still being built.
- It also complicates the mark's interpretation at any single locus. If H3K9me3 in fetal HSPCs sits over enhancers that PU.1 already occupies, then H3K9me3 there is not a simple off-switch, and a change in the mark at one element cannot be read as a change in that element's activity.
- E6established confidence 5 of 5: Multiple independent lines of evidence; treated as settled in the field.database
SETDB1 is a broad dependency across the CRISPR panel, not a selective one. Flattening every tissue block of the DepMap essentiality payload gives 1,258 screens with a gene effect, mean -0.5288, median -0.5025, minimum -2.5919, with 50.4% of lines below -0.5 and 6.1% below -1.0; in the 147 screens from the hematopoietic and lymphoid blocks the mean is -0.6491 with 63.3% below -0.5. In the same call and the same data version, MEN1 gives mean -0.3616 with 28.9% below -0.5 and a blood mean of -0.5831, while SUV39H1 gives -0.0575 and CBX5 -0.083.
Open Targets Platform GraphQL API, target.depMapEssentiality with all tissue blocks flattened, plus meta.dataVersion · Open Targets Platform; Broad Institute DepMap · Open Targets Platform 2026What this evidence cannot show
Rule 83: the payload carries no DepMap release identifier, only the Open Targets data version (year 26, month 06). Rule 84: no median-split proportion is reported and the fractions are against absolute thresholds. The side-by-side with MEN1 is NOT a selectivity comparison - a pan-panel mean is the wrong statistic for that, and this pair is exactly the broad-versus-selective case the rule warns about. The panel contains no infant KMT2A::AFF1 line. Panel-maximum guard cleared at 1,258 screens and a live POLR2A zero-screen control was run in the same call.
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- A broad dependency is evidence against a therapeutic window and is NOT evidence about the fusion biology in either direction. It is compatible with SETDB1 restraining fusion targets (a transcriptional effect over days) and with SETDB1 being needed for proliferation (a viability effect over three weeks), and it cannot arbitrate between [E2] and [E4].
- Floor compression: with half the panel below -0.5 and the blood arm deeper still, there is little dynamic range left in which fusion-selectivity could appear, so a KMT2A-rearranged-versus-comparator contrast on this gene would be close to uninterpretable - the same defect this graph records for HCFC1 and KAT8.
- E7moderate confidence 3 of 5: One strong study, or several smaller consistent ones.paper
SETDB1 abundance is degradation-controlled, and TRIM28/KAP1 is the protector. TRIM28/KAP1 is preferentially located on the telomeres of ALT cells and interacts with the telomeric shelterin/telosome complex; knocking down TRIM28 in ALT cells delayed cell growth, decreased C-circle levels, increased the frequency of ALT-associated PML bodies, lengthened telomeres and increased telomere sister-chromatid exchange; and mechanistically TRIM28 protects SETDB1 from degradation, thereby maintaining the H3K9me3 heterochromatin state of telomeric DNA.
TRIM28 inhibits alternative lengthening of telomere phenotypes by protecting SETDB1 from degradation. · Wang C, Songyang Z, Huang Y · Cell & Bioscience 2021What this evidence cannot show
Abstract level; ALT tumour cells, telomeres, not haematopoietic and not this locus. The abstract does not name the ligase that degrades SETDB1, so the parallel with CUL5-ASB7 on SUV39H1 is structural rather than mechanistic - and this entry does not claim ASB7 acts on SETDB1.
Evidence that argues against this (1)
- The compartment is telomeric heterochromatin in ALT-positive cells, which is a specialised state, and the readouts are ALT phenotypes. Whether SETDB1 abundance is degradation-limited in a haematopoietic cell at a euchromatic locus is untested, so this supports only the general point that a mark level can move without an enzyme-activity change.
- E8strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
The reader recruits this writer, and the reader is HP1-alpha specifically. The CHAMP1 complex - CHAMP1, POGZ and HP1-alpha - is enriched in heterochromatin, promotes heterochromatin assembly at multiple chromosomal sites including centromeres and telomeres, and promotes homology-directed repair of double-strand breaks in those regions; the complex binds and recruits the writer methyltransferase SETDB1 to heterochromatin regions and is required for efficient DSB repair there; and peripheral blood lymphocytes from individuals with CHAMP1 syndrome, an inherited neurological disorder caused by heterozygous CHAMP1 mutations, exhibit defective heterochromatin clustering and defective DSB repair.
CHAMP1 complex directs heterochromatin assembly and promotes homology-directed DNA repair. · Li F, Zhang T, Syed A, Elbakry A, et al. · Nature Communications 2025What this evidence cannot show
Abstract level; the cell lines used for the mechanism are not named in the abstract, and the only human primary material is peripheral blood lymphocytes from CHAMP1-syndrome individuals used as a repair-defect readout, not as a SETDB1-occupancy measurement. The recruitment is to heterochromatin, not to a euchromatic loop anchor. A 2025 paper with no replication known to this project.
Evidence that argues against this (2)
- It places SETDB1 recruitment by HP1-alpha in HETEROCHROMATIN, which is close to the opposite of the KMT2A exon-11 element's chromatin state - an active, transcribed, CTCF/cohesin-bound anchor. A heterochromatin-assembly complex need not operate there at all.
- A review of this literature notes that children with CHAMP1 syndrome have developed leukaemia, suggesting CHAMP1 mutations may be a cancer risk factor (PMID 42748571, DNA Repair 2026, a review and used only as a map). That is a reason to look, not evidence of a mechanism, and the leukaemias are not reported as KMT2A-rearranged.
- E9strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
CTCF recruits SETDB1 to double-strand breaks alongside SUV39H1. In U2OS and HEK-293T cells, CTCF recruits the repressive chromatin proteins HP1-gamma, KAP1, SUV39H1, SETDB1 and KDM5A, enabling rapid accumulation of BRCA1/BARD1 at DSBs; CTCF depletion abrogates the enrichment of these proteins with loss of H3K9 methylation at DSBs, and depriving any one component compromises the accumulation of the others and of BRCA1/BARD1, abrogating EXO1/DNA2 recruitment and end resection.
CTCF primes repressive chromatin for rapid BRCA1/BARD1 recruitment to drive homologous recombination repair of DNA double-strand breaks. · Hwang SY, Choi D, Choi MJ, Jo HR, et al. · Nucleic Acids Research 2026What this evidence cannot show
Abstract plus methods read from PMC13384258; systems are HEK-293T and U2OS DSB reporter lines with enzyme-induced breaks (AsiSI, FokI), so no endogenous locus and no blood cell. The HP1 paralogue named is HP1-gamma/CBX3 and is not transferred to CBX5 here. Reagents include etoposide and BIX-01294, a G9a/GLP inhibitor.
Evidence that argues against this (1)
- It makes SETDB1 and SUV39H1 indistinguishable at a break - both are recruited by the same protein in the same cascade - so the DSB route cannot be used to argue which writer matters at the KMT2A anchor. Only the resting-state compartment difference separates them, and that is a prior, not a measurement.
- E10strong confidence 4 of 5: Replicated in peer-reviewed work by more than one group.paper
SETDB1's one uncontroversial genomic address is the 3' exons of zinc-finger genes, co-occupied with TRIM28, ZNF274 and ATRX. A comprehensive ChIP-sequencing study of ATRX in multiple human cell lines identified the 3' exons of ZNF genes as a class of ATRX targets; these regions carry an atypical signature - transcriptionally active, high H3K36me3 and paradoxically enriched in H3K9me3 - and are co-occupied by SETDB1, TRIM28 and ZNF274, which form a complex with ATRX; CRISPR loss of ATRX or ZNF274 reduces H3K9me3 at the ZNF 3' exons, and cells with reduced H3K9me3 there show increased DNA damage.
ATRX binds to atypical chromatin domains at the 3' exons of zinc finger genes to preserve H3K9me3 enrichment. · Valle-Garcia D, Qadeer ZA, McHugh DS, Ghiraldini FG, et al. · Epigenetics 2016What this evidence cannot show
Abstract level. This is cited here for two reasons: it is UniProt's source for SETDB1's non-pericentromeric chromatin assignment, and it is the basis for the ZNF274 3'-exon positive control used in this beat's occupancy analysis. The co-occupancy claim is from ChIP-seq overlap plus complex formation, and the loss-of-function arms are ATRX and ZNF274 rather than SETDB1 itself.
Evidence that argues against this (1)
- A transcribed region that is paradoxically H3K9me3-enriched is a warning about this whole beat's inference: H3K9me3 and active transcription coexist at ZNF 3' exons, so finding H3K9me3 at a transcribed element like the KMT2A gene body would not by itself mean the element is silenced, and finding none would not mean the writers are absent from the gene.
SETDB1 is one of the repressive chromatin proteins in the same CTCF-primed DSB cascade
the two H3K9me3 writers, separable on compartment (pericentromeric/laminar/nucleolar versus non-pericentromeric and nucleolus-excluded) and on dependency (flat versus broad), and neither ever measured at the KMT2A locus
writes H3K9me3; the H3K9me3-specific methyltransferase of the pair, non-pericentromeric and nucleolus-excluded
PAF1c-SETDB1 raises promoter H3K9me3 at Hoxa9 and reduces its transcription in mouse MLL-AF9 cells; higher SETDB1 tracks with lower HOXA9 in human AML
PAF1c-SETDB1 raises promoter H3K9me3 at Meis1 and reduces its transcription in mouse MLL-AF9 cells
PAF1c interacts with SETDB1 in MLL-AF9 cells; the CDC73_3YF mutant stabilises the interaction and cannot support AML growth
- expressed in →Fetal liver haematopoietic stem and progenitor cell — the leading candidate cell of origin for t(4;11) infant ALL
required in mouse fetal liver HSPCs: Setdb1 deletion compromises stem-cell function, enhances myeloerythroid differentiation and impairs lymphoid development via cryptic-enhancer activation
TRIM28/KAP1 protects SETDB1 from degradation at telomeres, maintaining the H3K9me3 state; and the two co-occupy ZNF 3' exons with ZNF274 and ATRX
ATRX forms a complex with SETDB1, TRIM28 and ZNF274 co-occupying the 3' exons of zinc-finger genes, the one uncontroversial genomic address of this writer
CTCF recruits SETDB1 alongside SUV39H1, HP1-gamma, KAP1 and KDM5A to double-strand breaks (U2OS/HEK293T)
HIRA knockdown in K562 raises H3K9me3 and HP1-alpha through SETDB1, compacting chromatin toward the nuclear periphery
the CHAMP1-POGZ-HP1-alpha complex binds and recruits SETDB1 to heterochromatin and is required for homology-directed repair there
candidate explanation for the replicate-consistent H3K9me3 rise over the KMT2A BCR under BOTH single knockdowns in GSE210480, which is the wrong shape for a KDM3B-G9a balance - Q108 named SETDB1 redistribution as one of three candidates
measured-not-analysed rather than never-measured: three K562 ChIP-seq experiments existed and nobody had read them at this locus
reads three K562 SETDB1 peak sets and five signal tracks at the KMT2A locus: zero called peaks in the gene or within 50 kb, with the ZNF274 gene-body positive control passing
the first alternative writer - and it has no called peak at this locus in K562
answers gene-trim28's question: SETDB1 is NOT in the 960-protein network, so TRIM28 is there as a lone scaffold rather than a TRIM28-SETDB1 module
second H3K9 writer in the same CTCF-recruited assembly